Stourbridge made one change from Tuesday night's team, with new loanee Reece Hales coming in for his debut in attack, replacing the unavailable Will Richards.
After early pressure from Trafford, it was the Glassboys who largely held sway in the opening stages. However, the home side were first to get themselves on the scoresheet on 24 minutes when a through ball split the Stourbridge defence and Shelton Payne ran on to beat Dean Coleman with a low shot.
However, the Glassboys were level within five minutes thanks to a deft finish from Hales, flicking home Ramsey-Dickson's low cross.
The second half began with a bang - Benbow firing Stourbridge into the lead with little more than 60 seconds played, his fierce shot squirming through the fingers of Tom Read in the home goal.
But the advantage was gone even quicker this time around as Trafford were level within another 60 seconds. Dean Coleman raced out of his area to deal with a high-bouncing through ball, only to misjudge his kick and allow Michael Oates the simple task of rolling the ball into the unguarded net.
Chances came at either end in the remaining 43 minutes, with Trafford probably having the better of them, but ultimately the teams had to settle for a point apiece.